 |
Two-thirds of girls aged 6 to 9 said they'd like to look like the girl on the right. Neat. |
A barf-inducing study out of Knox College in Illinois, published in the psychology journal
Sex Roles, says that girls as young as six want to look "sexy." The study, which involved 60 girls aged six through nine, looked at how media consumption and maternal influence influence young girls' self-sexualization.
The upshot of the study, provocatively titled
Sexy Dolls, Sexy Gradeschoolers? is pretty much that as moms, everything is either our fault or our success, depending on which doll your kid picked, I suppose. The good news is that even if your kid watches a crapton of television, that in itself won't make your kid want to look like a Bratz doll.
However, I'm gonna go out on a limb here and wager that if you yourself want to look like a Bratz doll, that's probably going to trickle down. Also probably if you buy
these Halloween costumes.
You can read all about the study
here on Strollerderby. I even got to interview the lead researcher!
Here on SRMM, I thought I'd take a look at what my own kids had to say about the dolls. Researchers asked the girls four questions: which paper doll they thought looked more like them, which paper doll they'd rather look like, and which paper doll they'd rather play with. They also told the girls a neutral little story about "Leila," a girl who is popular at school, and then asked, "which doll is Leila?"
The study involved girls aged six through nine. Two of my daughters would have aged out of the study, but I'm interviewing them anyway. Also, boys weren't included, but Little Dude has lots to say about what girls wear, it turns out. The study didn't allow for commentary or discussion; it just had girls choose one or the other. My kids, of course, gave commentary.
The Peanut Butter Kid, Age 8:
 |
Two-thirds of the girls thought the doll on the left would be more popular. |
The Peanut Butter Kid is actually the only one of my kids who was in the target demographics for this study.
Which doll looks more like you? PBK chose the more modestly dressed one, although she said that if it was a hot day, she would wear shorts. "But the shorts would have to be longer. And there needs to be more shirt."
Which doll would you rather look like: PBK chose the more modestly dressed doll. "I don't want to wear just a little skirt and a bra. I think that's a little too little."
Which girl looks like she'd be more popular at school? "To the popular girls, it would be this one [points to the skimpy-dressed one], and in my world, it would be the other one. Not a lot of my friends would be wearing that kind of stuff."
Which doll would you rather play with? PBK chose the one with the skimpy outfit. "I like playing with the dolls and making them say [this next part is in a Sharpay / Valley Girl voice]
'Yah, that is totally in.' In my game, she would be a fashiony mean girl. Some people I know are kind of like that. Sometimes that's just how people are."
Cookie, Age 11:
Which doll looks like you? Cookie chose the more modestly dressed one.
Which doll would you rather look like? Cookie chose the more modestly dressed one. "It looks more comfortable, and also I don't want people to think of me as a popular girl. I want people to think of me as just awesome."
Which doll looks like she's more popular at school? Cookie chose the skimpily dressed one. "It seems like the girls who are popular and have more popular friends, all they care about is fashion and how they look. But it shouldn't be that way. Popularity should be about your personality, having a kind heart, and loyalty."
Which doll would you rather play with? Cookie chose the more modestly dressed one. "The games I play don't usually require a girl who looks like the other one."
Little Dude, Age 6:
First of all, I had to answer a bunch of questions for him about those red lace-up sandals before we could even have a conversation. (Did I cover those sandals in my
Top Ten Skankeriffic Sandals My Daughters Will Not Be Wearing This Summer?)
Which doll looks more like your sisters? Little Dude chose the more modestly dressed doll.
Which doll would you like your sisters to look like? Little Dude chose the more modestly dressed doll,
"because I don't want them to be really fashionable, or like girly-girls." Little Dude is also very uncomfortable when his sisters even wear bathing suits because it looks like underwear and people can see it. The Professor and I look forward to one day sending Little Dude along on the girls' dates as a chaperon.
 |
Everything you need to know about social hierarchy can be learned from Sharpay. |
Which doll would be more popular at school? He chose the girl in the skimpy outfit, "because she has that fancy stuff." He noted, however, that he wouldn't choose to sit next to that one at lunch, because "she looks mean." He would sit next to the more modestly dressed one, because "she looks nicer."
Which doll would you rather play with? Little Dude chose the more modestly dressed doll. "She looks nicer."
Pork Lo Maniac, Age 11
Which doll looks more like you? PLM chose the more modestly dressed doll, "because that's how I dress."
Which doll would you rather look like? PLM chose the more modestly-dressed one, "because
then I have less of a chance of getting skin cancer."
Which doll would be more popular at school? "It depends. Either one could be popular. The [one in the skimpy clothes] might be popular for getting in trouble. And because people would be gossiping, 'Did you hear Leila got in trouble?' Or it could be the other one. She could be popular, just because she's popular."
The researchers of the actual study found that girls as young as six had figured out that looking sexy is your ticket to popularity, and most of the girls wanted to look like the sexy, popular girl.
In my research, I found that my kids think:
- Dressing "fashionable" and "fancy" makes you popular.
- Popular girls are mean.
- The popular girls are possibly from another planet.
- Popular girls talk like Sharpay from High School Musical.
- Short-shorts look like they give you wedgies.
- Belly shirts should come with sunblock.
It's worth noting that nowhere in these conversations does the word "sexy" come up. My kids thought of the skimpy outfit as "fancy" or "fashion-y."
You know, I'm more disturbed by the whole mean popular girl thing than I am by the skanky outfits thing. Our culture gives girls a clear message that being popular means being a self-absorbed mean girl. That's a shame, partly because it's not really true. I went to a pretty big high school, and the girl voted Prom Queen was just super nice, athletic, and smart. Sure, some of the girls in the "popular" clique (that group was called the "Preppies" back in the day) were kinda bitchy, but so were some of the girls in every other clique.
I'd love to be able to say my kids picked up the "popular girls are mean" attitude from me, but I really try not to say that stuff in front of them. I also never refer to other people's clothes as "skankeriffic" out loud. (Just in print.) I'd love to be able to say that learned it all from Sharpay.
But that isn't it at all: What's happened is that they've already met popular mean girls. That crap started in second grade, and was full-blown by the second half of fourth grade.
(Image Credits: Paper dolls: Christy Starr, Knox College. Sharpay: FanPop.)